Aha, I don't know if I have bought an album twice. I had Pink Martini's Hang on Little Tomato, which I lost. I downloaded a copy from somewhere instead of buying it XP
(can't afford to buy over and over again)
There was the time I had a Pikachu plushie. My "friend" who lived down the street stole it and cut off its tail. Her mother had to buy a new one for me.